The keys to Gaston were already in Baybars’s hands when his men approached the castle. In the Catalan Rule of the Templars, one brother had taken them while the others were eating. The garrison now had to decide whether to hold a frontier castle without enough men or equipment, or leave without the permission the Order required.

After Antioch fell, Gaston was on its own

Gaston is another name for Baghras. The episode here is not Saladin’s siege of Baghras in 1188. In 1268, the Mamluk sultan Baybars took Antioch. According to clause 180 of the Catalan Rule, the Templar commander in the region, Gueraut de Suacet, had already asked Grand Master Thomas Bérard for men and supplies. No help arrived in time.

The rule says a brother named Gins de Belin took the keys to Baybars and told him the garrison wanted to leave. That detail comes from the Order’s account of the case, not an independent eyewitness record of the exchange. What matters for the decision inside the castle is that the commander could no longer assume the enemy was ignorant of his weakness.

Why the garrison chose La Roche Guillaume

According to the same account, the commander was initially prepared to stay. The sergeants said the position could not be defended and wanted to leave. The commander and the brothers eventually decided to withdraw toward La Roche Guillaume, a nearby stronghold in need of repair. They carried out what they could and destroyed part of what they left behind. The rule expressly says they did not destroy everything.

Bérard and the Order’s leadership reached the same conclusion separately: Gaston could not be held and they could not send relief. They dispatched a brother with a banner to gather the men if they had already left, or transmit the order to withdraw if they were still inside. The men at Gaston had acted before that authorization reached them.

Why the Order did not expel them

The question was not whether a knight could ride away whenever he thought a position hopeless. The rule treated abandoning a frontier castle without permission as grounds for expulsion. Some brothers argued for applying that rule. Others pointed out that the garrison had done exactly what the leadership wanted, though it could not yet know that. The Catalan account records a decision against expulsion, while treating the incomplete destruction as a fault.

The same passage says the leadership prayed that God would give the men the judgment to leave. That tells us what the rule’s account remembers them praying for; it does not prove supernatural intervention. It does show a striking distinction: the brothers could pray for a withdrawal and still ask how it had been carried out. Faith did not make accountability unnecessary.

The episode belongs next to, but is not the same as, the Templar rules for regrouping under a battle banner. Gaston asks a harder question about command: when you must act before an answer comes, can you explain what you protected, what you left behind, and why?

A song for the road not taken lightly

The Side Road, from Sword of the Templar, is a listening companion for that decision, not a retelling of the retreat. With Gaston in mind, explore Fabian Forge’s music on YouTube or listen to The Side Road on Spotify.

Explore the Fabian Forge discography and the faith behind the Christian heavy metal project.

For a much earlier case in which the account comes from outside the Order, read about the surrender of a Templar cave fortress in Transjordan.

Sources

The surviving accounts cited here do not give an unambiguous description of the lesser penalty; the account’s decision not to expel the men is the point at issue here.